FDA Warns Tom's of Maine Over Microbial Contamination in Toothpaste Manufacturing

Preview

Tom's of Maine, a well-known natural toothpaste brand, has recently come under scrutiny due to significant violations of Current Good Manufacturing Practice (CGMP) regulations. The FDA issued a warning letter to the company, highlighting several issues related to the production of their toothpaste products.

Preview

Key Violations and Issues

Microbial Contamination in Water:
- The company failed to follow appropriate written procedures designed to prevent objectionable microorganisms in drug products not required to be sterile. Specifically, multiple water samples used in the manufacturing process and for equipment cleaning were found to be contaminated with bacteria such as Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Ralstonia insidiosa, and Paracoccus yeei.
- Despite these findings, the company did not conduct adequate investigations to assess the impact on product safety and water system performance. For example, contaminated water was used to manufacture the "Tom’s Simply White Clean Mint Paste" and to clean equipment, but no thorough investigations were conducted.

Preview

Inadequate Water System Qualification:
- The water system used for equipment cleaning and product formulation was not adequately qualified. The installation qualification and operational qualification (IQ/OQ) were performed in October 2019, but the data was not evaluated until after the FDA inspection. The performance qualification (PQ) lacked analysis for total organic carbon (TOC) and conductivity, and did not address the absence of gram-negative microorganisms required in their product specifications.
- The company's response to these issues was deemed inadequate as it did not include sufficient evidence or testing results for the finished products. The response also lacked a thorough evaluation of the quality of OTC products already distributed that may have been impacted by the use of tainted water.

Preview

FDA's Demands and Recommendations

Comprehensive Assessment and Risk Evaluation:
- The FDA demands a comprehensive assessment of the design and control of the firm’s manufacturing operations, including a detailed review of all microbiological hazards.
- A detailed risk assessment addressing the hazards posed by distributing OTC drug products with potentially objectionable contamination is required. This includes specifying actions such as customer notifications and product recalls.

Preview

Investigations and Corrective Actions:
- Complete investigations into all batches with potential objectionable microbial contamination or out-of-specification (OOS) microbiological results are necessary. These investigations should detail the root causes of the contamination.
- Appropriate microbiological batch release specifications, including total counts and identification of bioburden to detect any objectionable microbes, must be established for each drug product.

Preview

Retesting and Corrective Measures:
- Retesting of reserve samples of all drug product batches within expiry is required, including testing for identity, strength of active ingredients, and microbiological quality. If testing yields an OOS result, corrective actions must be taken, such as notifying customers and initiating recalls.

Preview

Implications

The FDA's warning letter underscores the critical importance of adhering to CGMP regulations to ensure the safety and quality of pharmaceutical products. Failure to maintain proper controls and procedures can lead to serious health risks for consumers. The company must take immediate and effective measures to address these issues to prevent further contamination and ensure the safety of their products.

Preview

FDA Warns Tom's of Maine Over Microbial Contamination in Toothpaste Manufacturing

Preview

Key Violations and Issues

Microbial Contamination in Water:
- The company failed to follow appropriate written procedures designed to prevent objectionable microorganisms in drug products not required to be sterile. Specifically, multiple water samples used in the manufacturing process and for equipment cleaning were found to be contaminated with bacteria such as Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Ralstonia insidiosa, and Paracoccus yeei.
- Despite these findings, the company did not conduct adequate investigations to assess the impact on product safety and water system performance. For example, contaminated water was used to manufacture the "Tom’s Simply White Clean Mint Paste" and to clean equipment, but no thorough investigations were conducted.

Preview

Inadequate Water System Qualification:
- The water system used for equipment cleaning and product formulation was not adequately qualified. The installation qualification and operational qualification (IQ/OQ) were performed in October 2019, but the data was not evaluated until after the FDA inspection. The performance qualification (PQ) lacked analysis for total organic carbon (TOC) and conductivity, and did not address the absence of gram-negative microorganisms required in their product specifications.
- The company's response to these issues was deemed inadequate as it did not include sufficient evidence or testing results for the finished products. The response also lacked a thorough evaluation of the quality of OTC products already distributed that may have been impacted by the use of tainted water.

Preview

FDA's Demands and Recommendations

Comprehensive Assessment and Risk Evaluation:
- The FDA demands a comprehensive assessment of the design and control of the firm’s manufacturing operations, including a detailed review of all microbiological hazards.
- A detailed risk assessment addressing the hazards posed by distributing OTC drug products with potentially objectionable contamination is required. This includes specifying actions such as customer notifications and product recalls.

Preview

Investigations and Corrective Actions:
- Complete investigations into all batches with potential objectionable microbial contamination or out-of-specification (OOS) microbiological results are necessary. These investigations should detail the root causes of the contamination.
- Appropriate microbiological batch release specifications, including total counts and identification of bioburden to detect any objectionable microbes, must be established for each drug product.

Preview

Retesting and Corrective Measures:
- Retesting of reserve samples of all drug product batches within expiry is required, including testing for identity, strength of active ingredients, and microbiological quality. If testing yields an OOS result, corrective actions must be taken, such as notifying customers and initiating recalls.

Preview

Implications

Preview