Trump's Proposed Policies and Actions on Illegal Migration: Past and Future

Preview

Donald Trump has proposed several policies and actions to address illegal migration, both based on his past administration's actions and his current proposals for a potential second term. Here are the key points:

Past Policies on Immigration

Border Wall Construction: Trump's administration built over 400 miles of the southern border wall, which led to an 87% decrease in illegal crossings in those areas.

Preview
End of Catch-and-Release: The dangerous practice of Catch-and-Release was ended, ensuring that aliens are detained pending removal and ultimately returned to their home countries.

Preview
Asylum Cooperation Agreements: Historic asylum cooperation agreements were entered with Honduras, El Salvador, and Guatemala to stop asylum fraud and resettle illegal migrants in third-party nations pending their asylum applications.
Migrant Protection Protocols: A historic partnership with Mexico, referred to as the “Migrant Protection Protocols,” was established to safely return asylum-seekers to Mexico while awaiting hearings in the United States.
Expedited Removal: The administration fully enforced and implemented statutorily authorized “expedited removal” of illegal aliens.

Preview
National Security Travel Bans: Instituted national security travel bans to keep out terrorists, jihadists, and violent extremists, and implemented a uniform security and information-sharing baseline that all nations must meet for their nationals to travel and emigrate to the United States.
Sanctuary Cities: Signed an executive order to strip discretionary Federal grant funding from deadly “sanctuary” cities.

Current Proposals for a Potential Second Term

Mass Deportations: Trump has proposed the largest deportation operation in U.S. history, invoking 18th-century laws and reshuffling law enforcement at federal agencies to enforce immigration laws more strictly. This includes using local law enforcement and the National Guard to find and deport undocumented migrants living across the U.S., potentially including the building of detention camps and the activation of the military.
Secure Border Fund: Proposes a permanent, self-sustaining border security fund financed by fees and revenues generated at ports of entry to ensure law enforcement officers have the resources they need without waiting on Congress.
Merit-Based Immigration System: Plans to modernize the legal immigration process through a point-based merit system, increasing the number of legal immigrants selected based on skill or merit from 12% to 57%. This system would protect American jobs and wages, prioritize immediate families, and create a fair and transparent process for immigration.
Asylum Reforms: Aims to expedite relief for legitimate asylum seekers and promptly send those who abuse the system back home.
Integration Requirements: Green card applicants would need to pass a U.S. civics exam and demonstrate English proficiency before applying, prioritizing young applicants likely to build long-term ties and contribute to society over their lifetimes.

Expert Opinions on Trump's Immigration Policies

Feasibility and Impact: Experts have questioned the feasibility of mass deportations due to the enormous legal and practical challenges involved, including the need for vast resources and the potential impact on communities and the economy. Some experts believe that such proposals are more political statements than practical plans.
Historical Context: Trump often references the Eisenhower-era "Operation Wetback" as a model, but historians note that this operation was not as successful as claimed and faced significant legal and logistical hurdles.
Economic and Social Implications: Mass deportations would likely have profound effects on the U.S. economy and social fabric, including potential damage to mixed-status families and communities.

In summary, Trump's past policies focused on border security, ending the catch-and-release practice, and entering into historic asylum cooperation agreements. His current proposals for a potential second term include mass deportations, a merit-based immigration system, and significant reforms to the asylum process, all of which face considerable challenges in terms of feasibility and implementation.

Preview

Trump's Proposed Policies and Actions on Illegal Migration: Past and Future

Preview

Past Policies on Immigration

Border Wall Construction: Trump's administration built over 400 miles of the southern border wall, which led to an 87% decrease in illegal crossings in those areas.

Preview
End of Catch-and-Release: The dangerous practice of Catch-and-Release was ended, ensuring that aliens are detained pending removal and ultimately returned to their home countries.

Preview
Asylum Cooperation Agreements: Historic asylum cooperation agreements were entered with Honduras, El Salvador, and Guatemala to stop asylum fraud and resettle illegal migrants in third-party nations pending their asylum applications.
Migrant Protection Protocols: A historic partnership with Mexico, referred to as the “Migrant Protection Protocols,” was established to safely return asylum-seekers to Mexico while awaiting hearings in the United States.
Expedited Removal: The administration fully enforced and implemented statutorily authorized “expedited removal” of illegal aliens.

Preview
National Security Travel Bans: Instituted national security travel bans to keep out terrorists, jihadists, and violent extremists, and implemented a uniform security and information-sharing baseline that all nations must meet for their nationals to travel and emigrate to the United States.
Sanctuary Cities: Signed an executive order to strip discretionary Federal grant funding from deadly “sanctuary” cities.

Current Proposals for a Potential Second Term

Mass Deportations: Trump has proposed the largest deportation operation in U.S. history, invoking 18th-century laws and reshuffling law enforcement at federal agencies to enforce immigration laws more strictly. This includes using local law enforcement and the National Guard to find and deport undocumented migrants living across the U.S., potentially including the building of detention camps and the activation of the military.
Secure Border Fund: Proposes a permanent, self-sustaining border security fund financed by fees and revenues generated at ports of entry to ensure law enforcement officers have the resources they need without waiting on Congress.
Merit-Based Immigration System: Plans to modernize the legal immigration process through a point-based merit system, increasing the number of legal immigrants selected based on skill or merit from 12% to 57%. This system would protect American jobs and wages, prioritize immediate families, and create a fair and transparent process for immigration.
Asylum Reforms: Aims to expedite relief for legitimate asylum seekers and promptly send those who abuse the system back home.
Integration Requirements: Green card applicants would need to pass a U.S. civics exam and demonstrate English proficiency before applying, prioritizing young applicants likely to build long-term ties and contribute to society over their lifetimes.

Expert Opinions on Trump's Immigration Policies

Feasibility and Impact: Experts have questioned the feasibility of mass deportations due to the enormous legal and practical challenges involved, including the need for vast resources and the potential impact on communities and the economy. Some experts believe that such proposals are more political statements than practical plans.
Historical Context: Trump often references the Eisenhower-era "Operation Wetback" as a model, but historians note that this operation was not as successful as claimed and faced significant legal and logistical hurdles.
Economic and Social Implications: Mass deportations would likely have profound effects on the U.S. economy and social fabric, including potential damage to mixed-status families and communities.

Preview