Why Should Citizens Follow the Law if Leaders Don’t Have To?

Reasons for Following the Law

  1. Legitimacy and Authority:
    • The law is seen as a legitimate authority that coordinates people by working as a "focal point" to help avoid conflicts or undesirable situations. For example, a one-way traffic sign helps prevent head-on collisions, even without police enforcement.
    • Laws often signal new information or public attitudes, causing people to update their behavior. For instance, a new smoking ban can signal beliefs about the dangers of smoking, encouraging nonsmokers to confront smokers and potentially leading to a change in smoking behavior.
  2. Deterrence and Punishment:
    • Non-compliance with laws can lead to significant consequences such as fines, penalties, prison time, reputational damage, and disrupted business activities. These consequences act as deterrents to encourage adherence to the law.
  3. Social Contract:
    • Citizens and non-citizens have rights and responsibilities in their civic, political, and private lives. This includes voting, paying taxes, serving on juries, and participating in civic organizations. These responsibilities are essential for the survival of a free republic.
  4. Ethical and Moral Obligations:
    • There is an ethical and moral obligation for citizens to obey the laws of a political system. This obligation is distinct from the legal obligation and is based on the principles of justice and the common good.

Consequences of Not Following the Law

  1. Financial Penalties:
    • Non-compliance can result in substantial financial penalties. For example, GDPR violations can cost up to 4% of a company's worldwide annual revenue.
Preview
  1. Legal Repercussions:
    • Legal repercussions can include litigation, fines, imprisonment, and the revocation of licenses or permits. For instance, HIPAA violations can lead to fines ranging from $127 to $1.5 million per year, depending on the severity of the violation.
  2. Reputational Damage:
    • Reputational damage due to non-compliance can lead to a loss of trust from customers, investors, and other stakeholders, resulting in a decline in sales, drop in stock prices, and a tarnished brand image.
  3. Business Interruption:
    • Breaching laws can compel organizations to close operations until the issues are rectified, leading to reduced productivity and potential business failure.

Differences in Legal Obligations Between Citizens and Leaders

  1. Binding Nature of Law:
    • The law binds everyone, including citizens, government leaders, and officials. Lawmakers, judges, and officers of federal and state governments must take a specific oath to faithfully follow the U.S. Constitution, which is the "supreme law of the land".
  2. Historical Context:
    • Under historical monarchies, kings claimed divine right, making them subject only to God and not human laws. Modern world leaders generally do not invoke divine right, but some may claim the need to break laws to keep their people safe, which can lead to violations of civil liberties.

Why Should Citizens Follow the Law if Leaders Don’t Have to?

  1. Rule of Law:
    • The rule of law is fundamental to democracy and ensures that all individuals, including leaders, are accountable to the same legal standards. This principle makes democracy resilient and free.
  2. Social Contract and Responsibility:
    • Citizens have a responsibility to uphold the law to maintain peace, public order, and good health. This responsibility is part of the social contract that binds individuals to their community and state.
  3. Ethical and Moral Considerations:
    • Even if leaders do not always follow the law, citizens are expected to do so based on ethical and moral principles. This adherence helps maintain societal order and justice.
In summary, while there are significant reasons for citizens to follow the law, including legitimacy, deterrence, social contract, and ethical obligations, the legal system and societal expectations often differ between citizens and leaders. The rule of law underscores the importance of accountability and justice for all members of society.